Mummy Buzz

Jan
09
2015

Condo for Sale: Family Fined for "Too Noisy" Kids

Children being children, or Valid complaint?

Condo_Sale

Children will be children—unless of course you happen to live in a certain condo complex in Abbotsford, B.C., where a mom has been fined twice by her strata council because her two and five year-old kids are "too noisy."

This Crying Baby Turned A Flight Into A Combat Zone

Kathryn Mackenzie and her family bought the upper floor of a supposedly "family-friendly" complex, which is fully carpeted but for the kitchen. Her youngsters are proving too rambunctious for the downstairs neighbour, though. (Where is that volume switch when you need it?)

Following complaints, the strata sent two $50 fines via her condo statement for the noise infraction. Mackenzie is so conscious of volume, she allows her kids to jump on a foam mattress.

"I have a two year-old. He does scream, he has tantrums … I know it’s really loud. He's supposed to be loud. He's two years old and there’s nothing I can do to stop that," said Mackenzie. "For a year and a half now I am not parenting the way I would want to because I have to put this virtual stranger's comfort before the well-being of my children."

Part of the problem may be the construction of the wooden-framed complex, since noise—even the playful variety—travels two floors down in the basement. The downstairs neighbour claimed "the running and jumping is constant and doesn't stop and it is affecting our lives now too."
 
Mackenzie feels her kids are simply being kids and that if the complex did not welcome families, she should have been warned prior to purchase. The strata claims it is merely acting on its noise bylaw, applicable to all residents, which sounds reasonable enough.
 
Unfortunately for Mackenzie, it seems the strata is within its rights, as the mother of a screaming teenager in another complex was ordered to sell following more than 1,000 complaints.
 
Mackenzie has listed her home, and vows never to buy into a strata again. 
 
You tell me: Is this mom responsible for controlling her kids' noise levels?